Button Fly vs Zipper Fly: What’s the Difference

Button Fly vs Zipper Fly: What’s the Difference and Which Is Better?

When it comes to selecting a pair of jeans or chinos you may not consider the type of fly as an important factor. But to some - it can be!

Nonetheless the debate between button flies vs zipper flies has a rooted history. It's possible to find yourself at a crossroads contemplating not only convenience but durability too.

In this article I’ll shed some light on their advantages and disadvantages to help make the right choice.

fitted jean for men with zipper fly

What Are Button Fly Jeans?

Button fly jeans for men feature a front fastening system that uses buttons instead of a zipper. These jeans have a series of buttons on the fly that are used to close the front of the pants.

They are often associated with a vintage or classic style. Jeans with buttons instead of a zipper offer a different look and feel.

Is Button or Zip Fly Better?

The debate between button and zip fly is ongoing. Your choice will often depend on personal preference.

In my opinion, one isn't better than the other, they each have their perks and drawbacks. Factors such as durability and ease of use are perhaps the most important in making your decision. 

Why Do Some Jeans Use Buttons Instead of Zippers? 

The use of buttons in jeans or chinos has a history that actually predates the invention of zippers. Initially buttons were used as the main solution for keeping  two pieces of a garment together.

Because of its practicality, cost and ease  it remained a staple in the manufacturing industry.

From a durability standpoint, buttons tend to be more durable and less prone to breaking or wearing out over time.

With that being said, in poorly made garments buttons can pop off if they aren’t secured properly. Check the stitching on the underside of the button to make sure they are well made.

Advantages of Button Flies

Button flies have their advantages. Many people believe that they are more durable compared to zippers as there is a chance of a malfunction.

Although hidden, some do prefer the aesthetics of buttons over a zip.

Another benefit is that for males in particular buttons offer less risk of an intimate injury in comparison to a zip… if you get what I’m saying!


fitted chinos for men with zipper fly


Disadvantages of Button Flies

However there are also disadvantages to using button flies. They can take time to fasten and unfasten which may be inconvenient for some.

Additionally they can  sometimes create an outline under fitted tops potentially which can affect the silhouette and draw attention to an unwanted area - especially in a business casual setting.

Advantages of a Zip Fly

Zipper flies are well known for their convenience. They offer an effortless way to fasten your pants.

Additionally the sleek appearance of a zipper fly can enhance the profile of garments - particularly for fitted clothing it won't disrupt the shape which buttons sometimes can.

Disadvantages of a Zip Fly

One very minor but a common issue is that they can occasionally get stuck or break leading to potentially embarrassing situations.

As I also mentioned, if you are in a rush and don’t tuck certain areas away, the last thing you want is to zip over it - ouch! 

shop best fitting jeans with zipper fly

Button Fly vs Zipper Fly: Which is Better?

Ultimately, the choice between button fly and zipper fly depends on your personal preference.

Consider the durability of button flies against the convenience of zippers. Reflect on the aesthetic each provides and how it aligns with your style. Both have their place on garments.

In the clash of button fly closure vs zipper fly, there's no clear winner. Each has its merits and drawbacks, and the best choice varies from person to person.

Consider your needs, preferences, and the specific garments you're choosing between.

Ultimately the most important thing when buying clothing is how it fits.

shop best fitting jeans with zipper fly

Our tapered fit jeans provides comfort all day long. Exclusively designed with rugby players and muscular guys in mind, our jeans are crafted from 4-way stretch denim that is comfortable, robust and allows complete freedom of movement. 

Our team of leading tailors and industry experts have pioneered a unique Tapered fit that allows sufficient room for the thighs, glutes and calves whilst tapering in at the ankle, so there is no need to size up to fit your muscular build.

Ideal for muscular guys and rugby players.


Our revolutionary fit allows sufficient room for the quads, glutes and calves whilst tapering in at the ankle. 

Extra room in thighs and tapered at the ankle, no need to size up.


signature tapered fit jeans


Premium Stretch Denim

Super-soft, heavyweight cotton fabric provides comfort and freedom of movement all day long.


tapered fit jeans made out of premium stretch denim


Robust Build

Durable design that's built to last thanks to the hard-wearing fabric and reinforced seams.


Tapered fit jeans made from hard wearing fabric